Family businesses have long been romanticized as legacies handed down from one generation to the next. However, the reality is far more complex, and many business owners decide that transferring operations to family members simply isn’t the best path forward.
A recent survey by Edward Jones found that among financial advisors who work with business owners, 72% reported their clients do not plan to leave their businesses to family members. This trend reflects a shift toward strategic planning that focuses on business continuity, fairness among heirs, and personal preferences.
Below, we’ll explore the reasons business owners may not want their families to inherit the business, strategies for fair distribution of wealth when not all the kids will be getting a share of the business, and the importance of buy-sell arrangements, especially in light of the recent Connelly decision from the U.S. Supreme Court.
At C3 Financial Partners, we collaborate with clients and their advisors to help ensure their plans for their business are carried out per their wishes, whether that be to their family or otherwise.
It’s Not Just Rupert Murdoch: Reasons Business Owners Hesitate to Pass Their Business to Family
For many business owners, their enterprise often represents decades of hard work, financial risk, and countless personal sacrifices. With this level of personal investment, choosing the next steward of the business is both a financial and personal decision that forces the owner to consider multiple factors.
Here are a few common reasons business owners might not want family members to succeed them:
- Lack of Interest or Skills in the Family: Business ownership often requires a unique skill set and a high level of dedication that not all family members may share. Children or other relatives might not be interested in the field or willing to commit to its demands.
- Need for Professionalization: As businesses grow, especially in complex industries, owners may realize that future success depends on professional management. A family member without experience or specialized skills may struggle to run the business as effectively as an outside successor.
- Desire for Financial Security: Business owners may have retirement savings tied to their business assets, making a sale to a third party financially preferable to passing it down. Selling can provide a structured retirement, secure cash flow, and a clear financial separation from the business.
Estate Equalization: Helping Ensure Fairness Among Heirs
Choosing not to pass the business on to family members doesn’t mean business owners want to exclude their family from their legacy. Many business owners, especially those with multiple children, aim for an equitable distribution of assets among heirs. When the family business represents a significant portion of an estate, equalizing the estate can be a complex challenge.
Estate equalization offers a solution by giving heirs an equivalent amount in non-business assets. This method can prevent disputes, mitigate feelings of unfairness, and help avoid financial issues that can arise from trying to split business ownership among heirs.
For example, the business owner might establish life insurance policies, set up trusts, or transfer other non-business assets which can help ensure each heir receives an equal inheritance. While it might seem simple, estate equalization requires careful planning, often involving a life insurance policy purchased for the non-business heirs. This can provide liquidity and help offset the business’s high value within the estate, helping ensure heirs have similar financial benefits without needing to share in business operations.
Estate equalization not only serves to balance inheritance but also prevents heirs from potentially being tied to a business they have little interest or aptitude in managing. By effectively planning this aspect of estate distribution, business owners can alleviate familial conflict and keep the business running smoothly under new, perhaps external, leadership.
The Role of Buy-Sell Arrangements and the Connelly Decision
When planning for succession without a family transfer, establishing a buy-sell agreement can become essential. A buy-sell agreement is a legally binding contract that determines what happens to a business owner’s share in the business upon specific events such as retirement, disability, death, or sale. In the context of third-party succession, this agreement can facilitate a smooth transition and protect the interests of all parties involved.
In the recent case of Connelly v. The United States, the U.S. Supreme Court underscored the need for thorough and specific planning in buy-sell agreements. This decision emphasized that buy-sell agreements need to be comprehensive and account for valuation methods, timing, and possible conditions of the sale. A carefully crafted buy-sell agreement can protect the business from falling into financial turmoil in the transition phase and provide clarity on how an external sale would proceed.
Key Elements to Consider in Buy-Sell Agreements:
- Valuation: Setting an accurate valuation method is critical. The buy-sell agreement should clearly state how the business will be valued and updated regularly to reflect any changes in the business’s worth.
- Conditions and Triggers: Identifying and defining specific triggers for the buy-sell arrangement, such as death, disability, or retirement, can clarify when and how the agreement takes effect. This avoids ambiguity that could lead to legal disputes, particularly in cases where family members may still have a financial interest.
- Funding Mechanisms: Even a well-thought through buy-sell arrangement can run into issues if the parties do not address how the obligations in the agreement will be funded. This could include life insurance policies on the owner or a structured payment plan, helping ensure the new owner can afford the buyout without straining cash flow.
The Connelly decision serves as a reminder that buy-sell agreements should be tailored to the specific needs of the business owner and the anticipated successor, particularly if family members are not involved. By thoroughly detailing these elements, the agreement can protect the business’s value and can help ensure a seamless handover to a qualified, willing successor.
Navigating Business Succession and Continuity Without Family Involvement
Choosing a successor outside the family can open up unique opportunities for business continuity and growth. Outside buyers, including current employees, investors, or other entrepreneurs, may bring new skills and perspectives that can take the business to the next level. However, navigating this route requires forward-thinking planning and a proactive approach to succession or continuity arrangements.
Here are a few strategies for business owners considering non-family succession and continuity:
- Start Planning Early: Early planning enables a business owner to identify the right buyer, whether it’s an employee, another entrepreneur, or a private equity firm. It also allows time to structure estate equalization and buy-sell agreements in a way that aligns with the owner’s financial goals.
- Consider an Advisory Board: Bringing in outside advisors can provide valuable input on succession and continuity options and potential buyers. Advisory boards can also help prepare the business for a seamless transition by strengthening operations and identifying growth opportunities.
- Prioritize Communication with Heirs: If family members are not chosen to succeed in the business, open and honest communication is essential. This can help set expectations, explain the reasoning behind the decision, and offer a roadmap for estate equalization.
The Business Succession Plan and Continuity You Want
Opting out of a family succession doesn’t diminish the legacy a business owner leaves behind. On the contrary, strategic planning that includes estate equalization, and a well-structured buy-sell agreement, can help ensure that the business thrives, and all heirs are fairly considered, preserving the owner’s hard work and vision.
For business owners facing this decision, seeking guidance from experienced advisors can make all the difference, creating a transition plan that respects family dynamics, promotes business success, and honors the legacy of the business itself.
At C3 Financial Partners, we look forward to helping our clients gain clarity in their estate planning goals and objectives, confidence that they are making the right decisions as to where their legacy should go, and providing coordination with their other advisors to create and implement the right plan for them.
Securities offered through Valmark Securities, Inc. member FINRA, SIPC. Investment advisory products and services offered through Valmark Advisers, Inc., an SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Representatives may transact business, which includes offering products and services and/or responding to inquiries, only in state(s) in which they are properly registered and/or licensed. C3 Financial Partners is a separate entity from Valmark Securities, Inc. and Valmark Advisers, Inc.
This material is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual nor does it take into account the particular investment objectives, financial situation, or needs of individual investors.
